
In a chilling indictment unsealed this week, Tabitha Bundrick, 36, stands accused of orchestrating a calculated spree in which she allegedly used fentanyl‑laced drugs to incapacitate four men—and in doing so caused the deaths of three of them. Prosecutors say Bundrick lured victims between 2023 and 2024, often under the pretense of sex or drug transactions, then brought them to apartments where she administered substances she claimed were cocaine but which were secretly mixed with fentanyl.While the men were unconscious, she allegedly robbed them of phones, money, clothing, and other valuables, before fleeing the scene. In one case, a man awoke to find his friend, Mario Paullan, dead beside him with no memory of the night’s events. Bundrick was previously convicted on federal drug charges tied to the deaths and is currently serving a sentence of 156 months. Now, she faces 11 state charges, including three counts of second‑degree murder, robbery, burglary, and assault. Her attorneys argue she has mental health issues, intellectual limitations, and a traumatic past, contending she “never intended to kill anyone.”But the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office is treating the case as a “pattern” of lethal drugging and robbery, calling her alleged conduct “callous” and “extremely calculated.”