Former President Donald Trump’s decision to deploy the National Guard in several U.S. cities has ignited a fierce national debate over the balance between law and order and the limits of executive power. Supporters argue that the move is a necessary step to restore peace amid surging protests and civil unrest, framing it as a show of decisive leadership in turbulent times. Critics, however, warn that such deployments risk escalating tensions and blurring the line between civilian policing and military enforcement. Constitutional scholars have raised concerns about the long-term implications for democratic governance, questioning whether the action reflects legitimate security concerns or an alarming expansion of presidential authority. As America watches closely, the question remains whether this is a moment of stabilization—or a sign of political overreach cloaked in the name of public safety.