Summary: A 5-Year-Old’s Murder and Systemic Failure in Florida

The Tragic Incident
A 5-year-old girl from Tallahassee, identified as Missy Mogle, died on May 19 after suffering alleged abuse by her mother and stepfather 
Concerns emerged when it was revealed that authorities—specifically the Tallahassee Police Department and the Florida Department of Children and Families (DCF)—refused to release records related to prior investigations into suspected molestation by her stepfather nearly a year earlier

“Destined to Fail”
This case has sparked widespread grief and a growing wave of criticism suggesting that Florida’s child protection system is structurally incapable of safeguarding vulnerable children. The phrase “destined to fail” reflects widespread public frustration that, despite prior warning signs, protective measures were insufficient to prevent this tragedy

---

Historical Context: Recurring Failures in Florida’s Child Welfare System

1. Nubia Barahona (2011)

   • A 10-year-old girl was beaten to death by her adoptive father. DCF was widely criticized for its response—especially for failing to conduct timely or thorough investigations. A judge called the agency’s handling “inept” and a “failure of common sense.”

2. Ronnie Paris (2005)

   • A 3-year-old boy suffered fatal abuse shortly after being returned to foster parents. The Department of Children & Families (DCF) faced backlash for placing him back in an unsafe environment. The case highlighted systemic weaknesses in risk assessment and decision-making.

3. General Systemic Issues

   • Investigations have found that Florida’s DCF often investigates abuse allegations internally, raising concerns over conflicts of interest and leniency toward foster parents. Reporting thresholds for removing kids differ between biological and foster homes, signaling institutional shortcomings in prioritizing child safety.